Review: Traitor to His Class: The Privileged Life and Radical Presidency of Franklin Delano Roosevelt

Traitor to His Class: The Privileged Life and Radical Presidency of Franklin Delano Roosevelt by H.W. Brands
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

I've decided I prefer biographies that dedicate a large portion to the subject's childhood and formative years. I think most, if not all, of the decisions and actions taken later on in life, are somehow tied to how the person was raised, and who his/her influences were, etc. 

Unfortunately, this biography didn't seem to dedicate enough time to FDR's childhood, in my opinion. We do get a decent idea that he was given everything he could possibly want, and was possibly kept in too sterile an environment as a child (the author infers that the polio that struck him later may have had something to do with this), and was oozing self-confidence. Still, I would have appreciated more. 

Of course, when someone has gone through all that FDR has gone through, there is plenty of material from later on in life, so this book was by no means tedious or boring at any point. 

I had been curious to read it also because Herbert Hoover's biography painted a picture of FDR that was less than flattering; as someone who was more politically motivated than inclined to do what was right. I can't say this biography refuted that. FDR seemed very much to be an "end justifies the means" type of person. Of course, when the "end" is an end to the great depression or world war II, then it is difficult to disagree. 

Eleanor Roosevelt's role also seemed suspiciously vague. She obviously didn't like his affairs, and never really was close to FDR in a personal sense after a certain point, but she achieved a great deal in her own right. This wasn't her biography, so I didn't expect a play-by-play of her activities, but she seemed to come off as rather weak, and I suspect that wasn't really the case. 

View all my reviews

Review: Hoover: An Extraordinary Life in Extraordinary Times

Hoover: An Extraordinary Life in Extraordinary Times by Kenneth Whyte
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

One of the more interesting presidential biographies. Hoover reminded me a lot of John Quincy Adams. He was extremely prepared for the presidency in many ways, including a huge amount of international experience, from Shanghai to Burma to England. He and his wife spoke Chinese, and he was in Belgium during WWI and headed up relief efforts to get American aid through the German blockade to the Belgian population. 

However, like with Adams, his presidency was lackluster at best. He was hit with the great depression, which pretty much put a halt to all his plans. 

But after the presidency he went back to work, eventually working closely with Truman, Eisenhower and even Kennedy into his 80s. 

Some of my notes:

Smoot Hawley seems to have been the beginning of his downfall.

It will be very interesting to see how the FDR biography I will read treats the Hoover administration, the great depression and the New Deal. This book seems to infer that the depression was well into reversal by the time FDR entered office, and in fact, he actively kept out of a smooth transition since a continued fall under Hoover's watch would only benefit him later on. In other words, FDR is seen as an opportunist with few scruples, while Hoover's administration is "one of the cleanest" on record, with Hoover refusing to mention FDR's invalid state seeing it as a personal attack (my impression is it would have backfired regardless). 

Regardless, it is true that Hoover was probably the only cabinet member who preached moderation throughout the 20s and was probably one of the earliest to say there would be a reversal in the booming economy. So it is somewhat ironic that it happened during his presidency, and it is unlikely he could have done much more to combat it. In fact an FDR administration "insider", Rexford Tugwell, apparently said "The New Deal owed much to what (Hoover) had begun". Although the author goes on to say how FDR actually went much further than Hoover ever did with these policies. 

Another statement made by this book is that FDR's nationalization (and retreat from the gold standard) sent a message to other countries that they "had nothing to gain or fear from America". So Japan dropped out of the League of Nations and assaulted China, while Hitler assumed absolute power in Berlin. I'm very curious to see what an FDR biography says about that. 

Hoover was also dead against including the Soviet Union in the Lend-Lease act. 

This biography gives the impression that his reputation was vindicated by his death, but I confess all I knew about him before was that the great depression happened under his watch, Hoovervilles and the Hoover dam were named after him, and FDR followed him with a 4-term act. 

View all my reviews