Showing posts with label Book Review. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Book Review. Show all posts

Sunday, December 02, 2018

Review: Religion in Taiwan and China: Locality and Transmission

Religion in Taiwan and China: Locality and Transmission Religion in Taiwan and China: Locality and Transmission by Institute of Ethnology Academia Sinica
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

A collection of essays and articles. Once again, these are hit or miss. However, there was something interesting in each one of these for me. I either learned about a new person (Yu Yue), or a new sect (Yi-Guan Dao, which is apparently huge in Taiwan), or about a Chinese-born Christian sect (Local Church), or Chinese Sufism, or Shamanism for the Paiwan tribe. .

The Chapters:
1) In Search of the Original Scriptures. About a Japanese and a Chinese monk who try to find original Indian Buddhists scripts, mostly via London
2) Locality and Temple Fundraising in Northern Qing China
3) Yu Yue
4) Inside and Outside the British Settlement in Shanghai
5) The Construction of Fundamentalism in I-Kuan Tao
6) The problem of Locality. About the Little Flock, or the Local Church, the Chinese-born Christian sect.
7) Singing your own song? About New Age in Taiwan. Not sure why this would be considered religious, and the author seems to be criticizing one of the founders (and probably rightly so), but pretty interesting nonetheless.
8) Rituals as Local knowledge. How Several Indigenous populations relate to Millet.
9) A resurgent Temple. All about Fengtian temple in Xingang, Jiayi.
10) Decline and Revitalization of Shamanic traditions in Paiwan village. Relates it to Shamanism in Siberia and Korea. Also discusses how Christianity (and the Japanese and the KMT government) relegated these traditions and tried to get rid of them.
11) City of Saint. About Sufism in China. Quite fascinatin
12) Rivers and Lakes. About Diviners (fortune tellers, Feng shui experts, etc.)

View all my reviews

Saturday, December 01, 2018

Review: Pompeii

Pompeii Pompeii by Robert Harris
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

This book was excellent. Pompeii and the eruption of Mt. Vesuvius is something we've all heard about. I thought I had heard quite a bit about it, and I also went to visit Pompeii several years ago, and yet it wasn't until reading this book that I felt I got a real sense of what it must have been like to go through this ordeal. I've heard it said that A Tale of Two Cities does a better job than any history book of conveying what it was like to go through the French Revolution, and I suspect this is its equivalent for Pompeii and its inhabitants.

I also enjoyed the angle, and how the observations started from the changes in the water supply and aqueducts.

The (love) story in itself was a tad simplistic, but there were many other reasons to enjoy this book. The story was almost just an excuse to tell all the rest.

Also (SPOILER AHEAD) it seemed to be a bit of a stretch how Attilius manages to be on Mt. Vesuvius when the eruption starts, passes through Herculaneum and then Misenum, and the gets to Pompeii for the final pyroclastic surge (and obviously survives).

View all my reviews

Tuesday, November 27, 2018

Review: Voices from the Beautiful Island

Voices from the Beautiful Island Voices from the Beautiful Island by Chiu, Tzuhsiu Beryl
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

A nice collection of bilingual poetry and stories from various authors, with the Chinese and English side by side. My favorites were "Spring rain" (春雨), by Cheng, ching-wen, and "Soul Palanquin" (魂轎), By Tonfang Po.

Apparently the version of Spring Rain is slightly altered here, at least the English translation is. I also noticed there is a story by Husluman Vava, which was featured in The anthology of Taiwan indigenous literature, and this was different as well. I'm not sure why in either case.

Still, a good mix, also with an indigenous story and an ode to the military compounds that many mainland Chinese grew up in when they came here.



View all my reviews

Friday, November 23, 2018

Review: Twain’s Feast

Twain’s Feast Twain’s Feast by Audible Originals
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

More of a chat amongst friends than a book. If these friends happen to be experts on Mark Twain or subjects related to him.

This is also a fascinating journey into certain aspects of Americana from Mark Twain's time, stemming from a couple dishes and types of food he writes about.

It would have been much better had they actually tried eating the food mentioned (every dish seems to be a "vegetarian" or "Wagyu beef" version of what Mark Twain once had). It would have been interesting to at least hear what his favorite foods tasted like.

Very anecdotal, very colloquial, but also entertaining.

View all my reviews

Wednesday, November 21, 2018

Review: A New Illustrated History of Taiwan

A New Illustrated History of Taiwan A New Illustrated History of Taiwan by Wan-yao Chou
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

This is probably the definitive history of Taiwan to read (in English) for those who are interested in the subject. It is actually quite a quick read, and the illustrations are excellent.

The complicated history of how Taiwan feels vis-a-vis Japan, China, the ROC, and Taiwan itself is outlined very clearly, as well as how its history relates to the region, including Okinawa and Korea. I also appreciated that the author touched upon issues such as the frivolity of the news in Taiwan, which one notices when living here, but is hardly ever addressed.

A couple of my notes:
- The name "Taiwan" comes from an indigenous word
- Japan was able to use Taiwan to have China recognize it (Japan) as ruler of Okinawa
- Suniuo, an Amis, went to Indonesia as a soldier for Japan, and then hid in the forests of Indonesia for 30 years following the defeat of Japan in WWII.

A couple issues:
Why Wade-giles?? I understand it might have made sense when it was first written, in the 90s, but now they include a Wade-giles - Pinyin glossary at the end, which seems would be more trouble than just changing everything to Pinyin.

Would be interesting to have an update for the past 20 years or so, especially the whole China-Taiwan relationship and lack of recognition on an international stage, and maybe another look at the 90s from more of a historical perspective. An update would make me revise this to 5 stars.

View all my reviews

Tuesday, November 20, 2018

Review: Blitzscaling: The Lightning-Fast Path to Building Massively Valuable Companies

Blitzscaling: The Lightning-Fast Path to Building Massively Valuable Companies Blitzscaling: The Lightning-Fast Path to Building Massively Valuable Companies by Reid Hoffman
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

Maybe I'm just getting old, but I'm not sure how I feel about these books that try to make a point without any sort of comprehensive study, just some personal anecdotes of the author's. Granted, the author giving the personal anecdotes is one of the biggest success stories out there.

This also seems to apply only to people trying to make their businesses go viral, so it might not be applicable to B2B companies, or local restaurants, etc. To be fair, he addresses this (around halfway through the book), but he then states that most businesses will be online businesses (or already are). While this is true, it would have been handier (and frankly, more honest), to state this at the beginning, or on the dust jacket, so people who pick this book up know who its target market is right away.

All of this isn't to say I don't believe in his message. On the contrary, for some businesses this book is probably essential reading. This may even, at some point, include mine, in which case I should probably re-read it at that point. In the meantime, these are some of the notes I took:

The only time to blitzscale is when you have determined that speed is THE critical strategy to achieve massive outcomes. (This means greater uncertainty)

8 Transitions in Management Innovation:
1. Small teams to large teams
2. Generalists to Specialists
(Marines, army and police analogy)
3. Contributors to managers to executives
4. Dialogue to Broadcasting
5. Inspiration to Data
6. Single focus to multi-threading
"Freedom just means you have nothing to lose"
7. Pirate to Navy
(If I wanted to compete with myself, what would I do?)
8. Scale yourself (Founder to leader)

Always have a Plan A, Plan B, and Plan Z

Launch a product that embarrasses you (no time for perfection)



View all my reviews

Sunday, November 18, 2018

Review: Stephen Fry's Victorian Secrets

Stephen Fry's Victorian Secrets Stephen Fry's Victorian Secrets by Stephen Fry
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

A delightful listen. Of course, these are all anecdotes - so don't expect a thorough or scientific study of any sort - and they concentrate on the scandalous, outrageous, etc. etc. But still, impeccably narrated, and with many interesting tidbits, facts and names that I had never heard before.

You also get to hear a recording of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle speaking!




View all my reviews

Friday, November 16, 2018

Review: Down the Common: A Year in the Life of a Medieval Woman

Down the Common: A Year in the Life of a Medieval Woman Down the Common: A Year in the Life of a Medieval Woman by Ann Baer
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

This was a very pleasant surprise. Picked this up on spec in a used book store in Southern Taiwan. I was afraid it would be overly simplistic, or a children's book or something along those lines. It turned out to be entertaining and, as far as I can tell, quite accurate. The author goes into so much detail, it is obvious she has a passion for this subject (and she illustrated the book as well!).

All in all, an excellent perspective on life for a medieval woman somewhere in England, and it also makes you wonder how many stories like this there have been throughout time: people living their lives, with their family, friends, neighbors, dreams, desires, and thoughts.





View all my reviews

Thursday, November 08, 2018

Review: Discovering Language

Discovering Language Discovering Language by Thomas Nash
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

So this is a textbook, complete with exercises at the end of each chapter. It is a Linguistics primer, and the target audience is English speaking students in Taiwan. Taking all this into account, it is a rather interesting book, especially if English and Chinese are two of your languages. 3 stars, but rounded up to 4 because I should have know it would be a normal textbook ahead of time.

Some interesting notes:
- Words with /sl/ are said to convey unpleasant associations (slime, slither, slug, sloppy, etc.)
- Most words ending in -ump suggest heaviness and bluntness (rump, dump, hump, mump, lump, chump, thump, bump)
- The section on the different ways of being polite for Americans vs. Chinese (P. 55)
- The p's in the words "pit" and "spit" are pronounced differently, though English speakers do not normally realize this.
- Relatively new in-fix in English: "ma" (as in edu-ma-cation)
- Peoples' names have become common words: lumberjack, jack of all trades, Tomboy, tomcat, jimmy open
- 蒙古大夫 for a quack
- Languages with inclusive and exclusive "we": Taiwanese, Quechua, Tok Pisin, Hawaiian
- "gamel" became gamble. Same process added "d" to thunder and tender, and "p" to empty
- "Dog" used to mean a certain breed, and "hound" meant all breeds of dogs. Now the opposite.
- Silly used to mean Happy, then naive, now Foolish.
- Want used to mean "lack"


View all my reviews

Monday, November 05, 2018

Review: Cultural Discourse in Taiwan

Cultural Discourse in Taiwan Cultural Discourse in Taiwan by Chin-Chuan Cheng
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

A collection of essays, most of which deal with Taiwanese literature in some form. As with any collection of essays, these are hit or miss. Some points I found interesting:

- The similarities between post-war Taiwan and Korea, from having a (US-backed) dictator, to the Kaohsiong incident in 1979 and the Kwangju uprising in 1980, to protests and gradual reform, to democratic elections (Seoul olympics in 88 and Chiang Ching-kuo's death in 87 both helped).
- The essay on Malaysian-Chinese authors in Taiwan.
- The ancestral origin entry in birth certificates was only removed in 1992!
- The whole essay on the various origins of people living in Taiwan

Also, most of the essays seem to mention or refer to Homi Bhabha's "The Location of Culture" for some reason, so I think I should read that at some point.

View all my reviews

Thursday, November 01, 2018

Review: Under the Phoenix Tree

Under the Phoenix Tree Under the Phoenix Tree by Catherine Dai
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

I enjoyed reading this book. It deals with a family of 外省人, or Chinese who came to Taiwan to escape the communists. I don't usually enjoys these types of books too much because the stories are usually just about how much they miss their home province, but this was interesting. A story of a family in Taiwan, which is changing from a more traditional place to a more modern one. I especially enjoyed the little anecdotal stories about Taipei's history, like how Tianmu (allegedly) got its name, and the first foreign coffee shop in Taipei (Cafe Astoria), etc.



View all my reviews

Tuesday, October 30, 2018

Review: The Wind-Up Bird Chronicle

The Wind-Up Bird Chronicle The Wind-Up Bird Chronicle by Haruki Murakami
My rating: 5 of 5 stars

Why can't Murakami novels just last forever so I can just keep living in his weird world? Instead I need to wake up and deal with a lack of wells, not counting bald heads, no cats that disappear and turn up again with a new tail, not having to worry about water, or a lack thereof, or baseball bats, or a lack thereof.

Once again I feel like there's a bunch of symbolism I don't get, but I do enjoy the experience.

View all my reviews

Tuesday, October 16, 2018

Review: The anthology of taiwan indigenous literature - Short Stories

The anthology of taiwan indigenous literature - Short Stories The anthology of taiwan indigenous literature - Short Stories by Chang fang-ming
My rating: 3 of 5 stars

A collections of short stories, which were sort of hit or miss. Some were basically a list of customs and beliefs of a tribe, with a semi-story as a sort of excuse to name them all. Also, it's hard to retain much since pretty much each short story deals with a different tribe.

Still, interesting for those who wish to know more about the indigenous Taiwanese. I was also quite happy that one of the stories dealt with Orchid island, since it's hard to find their stories, and they're somewhat different from the other tribes.

All in all, however, short stories don't seem to delve deep enough to really get a feel for each tribe.

View all my reviews

Tuesday, October 09, 2018

Review: The Artist's Journey: The Wake of the Hero's Journey and the Lifelong Pursuit of Meaning

The Artist's Journey: The Wake of the Hero's Journey and the Lifelong Pursuit of Meaning The Artist's Journey: The Wake of the Hero's Journey and the Lifelong Pursuit of Meaning by Steven Pressfield
My rating: 2 of 5 stars

It might just be my impression but I felt like he bit off more than he could chew here. This book is *much* more philosophical than the other books I've read by him ("Do the work" and "The War of Art"), and I felt like it missed the mark. He quotes Jung, Marx, Homer, Joseph Campbell, and many others, but just seems to pick and choose random quotes or tidbits. I couldn't help feeling like he wanted to sound philosophical, but wasn't sure exactly how.

I did like some of the points he made, such as how all artists create empathy through their art (not sure if it's all that true for songs, but definitely seems true for books, movies and paintings).

I also liked his notion of following the muse. I just don't think he had to justify it with so many odd references.

Probably 2.5 stars. I would recommend checking out some of his other books first.

View all my reviews

Review: The Drucker Lectures : Essential Lessons on Management, Society and Economy

The Drucker Lectures : Essential Lessons on Management, Society and Economy The Drucker Lectures : Essential Lessons on Management, Society and Economy by Peter F. Drucker
My rating: 5 of 5 stars

I'm a fan of Drucker's and I really liked "The Effective Executive", but this collection of essays still surprised me, and very pleasantly. He has a quote at a certain point:

"Every 3 or 4 years I pick a new subject. It may be Japanese art; it may be economics. So for more than 60 years I have kept on studying one subject at a time."

This is reflected in his lectures. He covers a great many topics, and I was constantly surprised at how prescient he was, from the 40s to the 2000s. There were a few faulty predictions here and there, and some odd statements (about how deregulation would make Japan richer, but was still socially unacceptable, as an example), but by and large many of his statements from over 40 years ago still apply today.

Some passages I highlighted:

"The Ford Motor Company, we say, abandoned the Edsel. Well, this is polite euphemism. You and I abandoned the Edsel."

"The moment you can manage, you are no longer underdeveloped. You may still be poor, but you know how to get out of poverty fast."

"for there is no more conservative cause in the most profound sense of the words than the maintenance of the balance between man and his environment."

"American education tomorrow will no longer assume that one stops working when one starts working"

"Until very recently, there was no industry around for which the basic technological foundations had not been laid before World War I"

"Information is something that is pertinent to the task that can be converted into knowledge. And knowledge is information in action."

"He found in the orchestra's contract that they had to play five evenings, and he said, "No, you are going to be on duty 5 evenings, but you play 4. The fifth evening you sit out in the audience and listen.""

"And let me say the greatest weakness of our nonprofit institutions is that they don't reimburse. They have tremendous resistance against acquiring additional knowledge and skill on the part of their people, and it's stupid. It's very, very shortsighted, and it doesn't save anything. It costs money."

"74% of the people who work for Toyota are not on the Toyota payroll but on the payroll of contractors, suppliers, and have been for a long time. This is what makes "life-time employment" possible in Japan"

5 fundamental questions that every enterprise, profit or nonprofit, should be required to answer: What is our mission? Who is our customer? What does the customer value? What are our results? What is our plan?"

"And when the job becomes simply a a place to hang your hat, when it's "Thank God It's Friday", when you being to play games with yourself so that it makes the job more complicated, then you are bored. And boredom is a deadly disease."

"If you had no Department of Agriculture, would we now start one?"

"Whenever you do something of significance, whenever you are making an important decision, and especially whenever you are making a decision about people, you write down what you expect the results to be."

"The department stores in the United States and Japan are in terrible trouble" (written in 1996)

"No organization can possibly survive if it is both labor intensive and capital intensive. This is Economics 101."

"Is there a world economy? The answer is both yes and no. Economically, the world is becoming steadily more integrated. But politically the world is more likely to splinter."

"Total sales have tripled, while employment is a quarter of what it was. They think the company has become more productive. No. It has outsourced."

"one of the major challenges ahead is the fact that politics, military might, and economics no longer move in complete parallel but diverge."

"the fewer farmers there are, the more protection they get in every country"


View all my reviews

Sunday, October 07, 2018

Review: A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's Court

A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's Court A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's Court by Mark Twain
My rating: 5 of 5 stars

It took me a while to get into it (maybe the first chapter), but after that it was excellent. They really need to create a modern day version of this. Possibly a movie. Obviously most things are tongue and cheek, although the ending is a bit different.

I listened to the audio version, narrated by Nick Offerman, and he was excellent as well.

The only quote I jotted down:
"It reminded me of a time thirteen centuries away, when the "poor whites" of our South who were always despised and frequently insulted by the slave-lords around them, and who owed their base condition simply to the presence of slavery in their midst, were yet pusillanimously ready to side with the slave-lords in all political moves for the upholding and perpetuating of slavery, and did also finally shoulder their muskets and pour out their lives in an effort to prevent the destruction of that very institution which degraded them."

View all my reviews

Monday, October 01, 2018

Review: The China Study: The Most Comprehensive Study of Nutrition Ever Conducted and the Startling Implications for Diet, Weight Loss, and Long-term Health

The China Study: The Most Comprehensive Study of Nutrition Ever Conducted and the Startling Implications for Diet, Weight Loss, and Long-term Health The China Study: The Most Comprehensive Study of Nutrition Ever Conducted and the Startling Implications for Diet, Weight Loss, and Long-term Health by T. Colin Campbell
My rating: 3 of 5 stars



I'm in no position to question his findings, nor his methods. He does call out several other diets and nutritionists by name (South beach, Atkins, Perlmutter, Paleo, etc.). I find it interesting to note the points in common between all these diets and books: More veggies, fruits, nuts, beans, berries, etc. The difference seems to lie in meat, grains, animal products.

He's very much against isolating chemicals and finding benefits/disadvantages to each, since he says the way they all interact together is what matters (eating food vs. taking pills with isolated compounds).

If I were to play devil's advocate, I'd say that many of the studies mentioned (not all) seem to have a low number of participants (below 100), in contrast he seems to go into great detail to debunk studies that oppose his WFPB diet.

Toward the end the tone shifts (actually more or less the whole second half). He starts discussing how and why other scientists and lawmakers disagree with his findings. I won't opine on this, although for the most part it seems pretty credible.

Also,if you're calling the book "The China Study", I appreciate including other studies and information, but there should be much more about the China study. It is almost added as an afterthought at the end (it is mentioned throughout, but the study itself is only explained in more detail at the end). Even then, it has lots of ambiguity ("several suspect results were thrown out" sounds suspect in itself. How many is several? What criteria were there for judging them 'suspect'?)



Some of my notes:
US spends more on healthcare than any other country
US healthcare system is the 3rd (after heart disease and cancer) leading cause of death in the US.
Doesn't just cover China study
Premise: Too much protein (animal protein, Casein) is bad for us. --> Opposite of most diets (low on carbs, high on protein)

Study on Sodium nitrite:
1970: Journal Nature said Nitrite in our hotdogs may create nitrosamines (carcinogens)
Why: Animal experiments
Study: 2 groups of rats exposed to different levels of NASR (type of nitrosamine). Low dose received 1/2 amount of high dose.
Low dose: 35% died of cancer.
High does: 100% died of cancer.
BUT-->
The low dose, translated into human terms: 270,000 bologna sandwiches with 1 pound of bologna each, per day, for 30 years. This is how much rats in Low dose group had per bodyweight.
But studies with casein protein brought about cancer in 100% of test animals, and without the protein: 0% of animals.

Says he had nothing to gain in discovering this, and everything to lose, but then says those who pay his grants were reviewing his studies--> so it had to work out.

Cholesterol below 150 mg per deciliter means no heart disease according to most doctors.
He calls out Perlmutter by name.

"Hardly any study has done more damage to the nutritional landscape than the Nurses' Health Study, and it should serve as a warning for the rest of science for what not to do."

Interestingly, it mentions the Mcdougall plan, which I then looked up:
(From Wikipedia): The McDougall Plan—is a fad diet that carries some possible disadvantages, such as a boring food choice and the risk of feeling hungry."
Is it a fad diet if those are the only "possible" disadvantages? No mention of possible advantages.
So maybe he's onto something when he says the industry has a smear campaign going against nutrition-centered care. Then again, maybe he just knows people will oppose his findings so he's preemptively going after them.



View all my reviews

Sunday, September 30, 2018

Review: The Stolen Bicycle

The Stolen Bicycle The Stolen Bicycle by Wu Ming-Yi
My rating: 5 of 5 stars

So, this book was longlisted for the Man Booker prize, and there was some controversy since Man Booker first listed the author as Taiwanese, then switched to Chinese (under pressure from Beijing), which made the author protest on his facebook page. Anyway, the book didn't make the shortlist, and I can't help thinking the whole China/Taiwan drama may have had something to do with it.

Regardless, this was an excellent book, although this may be partly because I love Taiwan, and this book is thoroughly Taiwanese. It delves deep into certain aspects of Taiwanese history that I otherwise would know nothing about. In the process you also get a more Japanese perspective of certain events in WW2.

It's certainly not a clean, straightforward narrative, but it branches out into many avenues. I won't say it gets sidetracked, since the narrator is always in pursuit of the same thing (the bicycle), but in doing so a lot of ground is covered.

There's quite a bit of interesting symbolism (holding onto peoples' waists while riding a bicycle behind them, to then being the person in front with someone holding on behind. Also the parallels between the inanimate bicycle and the animate elephant, and I'm sure there are plenty more I've missed).

The postscript is beautiful. And thanks to it I found my favorite Jonathan Franzen quote: "Fiction meant taking up whatever the world had abandoned by the road and making something beautiful out of it."

A pet peeve though: The Chinese transliteration was really weird. Most of it was done using Wade-Giles (who does that anymore?), but some seemed haphazard (Ssu-Chuan for Sichuan/Szechuan)? I do wish I could read this in the original Chinese though, since I heard his prose is very poetic. I think some of this comes across in translation, but I'm sure a lot of it is lost.

If you're going to read one work of contemporary Taiwanese fiction, this should probably be it.


View all my reviews

Tuesday, September 25, 2018

Review: The Mysterious Etruscans

The Mysterious Etruscans The Mysterious Etruscans by Steven L. Tuck
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

Excellent overview of the Etruscans, which had been very hard for me to find, whether in English or Italian.

There seemed to be a couple times where he was overreaching and exaggerating a bit. I understand that the evidence is limited, so we have to guess and surmise quite a bit, but sometimes it just seemed taken a tad too far (No, the Romans would not have been going around in fig leafs if the Etruscans hadn't given them togas).

But I shouldn't overemphasize the fact. It doesn't detract (too much) from the overall story of the Etruscans.

Some of my notes:
Ostrich eggs were signs of international trade. Some were engraved by Phoenicians, others by Etruscans.
Warfare: Etruscans were very courageous, but bad at overarching strategies (just charge in for personal glory/machismo, with no real macro strategy)
Women had more power than Greece. Portrayals of childbirth and child rearing. Also literature aimed at women. Also portrayals of women at games and religious rites.

"The Etruscans are almost completely responsible for for the western notion of family, and they originated the very idea of the Family name in Europe."

"Tuscany" comes from the Latin for 'Etruscan'. "Tyrrhenian" comes from the Greek for 'Etruscan'. "Rome" comes from 'Rumon', the Etruscan word for the Tiber river.
Etruscan games were always religious in nature, so bleeding (although not necessarily death) was required in fights as an offering, unlike in Greek games. This then led to Gladiator fights of Ancient Rome.
More things we got from the Etruscans: togas, and aqueducts and stone archways were Etruscan inventions. Agrippa was Etruscan too.
Etruscan was still being used (at least in temples) up to the 4th century (so pretty much to the end of the Roman empire).
Capua (Etruscan city) sided with Hannibal, since he was fighting the Romans.

View all my reviews

Sunday, September 16, 2018

Review: The Coming Storm

The Coming Storm The Coming Storm by Michael Lewis
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

I feel like Michael Lewis is a genius at finding interesting topics in nooks and crannies others would have never thought to look. This is another one, showing how basically Barry Myers, slated to be the next head of NOAA, could (and is likely to) suppress weather data, thereby literally killing people, if he is confirmed.

I don't doubt that Myers is basically a gangster. From what little I've read about him (aside from this book), it sounds like he is, and wouldn't flinch at trying to gain personally at the expenses of citizens. However, this book would have been more interesting if Lewis had interviewed someone else at Accuweather. He mentions that Myers declined an interview, which is understandable actually, but there are other board members and employees (and former employees).

I always figured the NWS collected the data, and then companies, like Accuweather, could run their analyses on it (as well as on other data from other countries), and come up with their products. Like market research agencies use demographic data. If Accuweather comes up with good info (or can convince people they do), then they can sell it.

Of course, saying idiotic statements like 'we don't need the NWS because Accuweather is better' is like saying we don't need the census data because Nielsen has more useful reports, but that doesn't mean the private company has no use.

Anyway, a lot of the information was maddening, and Myers is most likely a terrible choice for head of NOAA, but I also think this book could have used more input from the other side.


View all my reviews